Google Reviews vs. Yelp: Which One Actually Brings You More Customers in 2025?
If you’re a local business owner, you’ve probably asked yourself: “Should I focus more on Google reviews or Yelp?”
Both platforms let customers rate your business, but in 2025 the winner is clear — one platform drives far more visibility, trust, and paying customers. Let’s compare.
Why Google Reviews Are King in 2025
1. Visibility in Search Results
When someone types “plumber near me” or “best tacos Kauaʻi”, Google shows your Business Profile front and center — complete with your star rating. That first impression happens before Yelp even comes into play.
2. Direct Impact on Local SEO
Fresh, high-quality Google reviews are one of the most important ranking factors in local SEO. The more positive reviews you earn, the higher your chances of appearing in Google’s “map pack” (the top 3 results with maps). Yelp reviews have no direct effect on your Google rankings.
3. Instant Trust Factor
Most customers won’t even click through to Yelp. They make a decision in seconds based on your Google stars. A 4.8-star rating with recent reviews is more persuasive than a stale Yelp page.
When Yelp Still Matters
Even though Google dominates, Yelp isn’t completely irrelevant.
-
Niche Industries: Restaurants, salons, spas, and some tourist-heavy businesses still see customer activity on Yelp.
-
Apple Maps Integration: Many iPhone users rely on Apple Maps, which pulls reviews directly from Yelp.
-
Extra Credibility: If you already have reviews there, keeping the page accurate helps.
But if you have limited time and budget, Yelp should never take priority over Google.
The Smart Strategy: Prioritize Google, Maintain Yelp
Here’s how successful local businesses approach it:
-
Spend 80% of your review effort on Google.
-
Share your Google review link via text or email after each job.
-
Grow reviews steadily — a few every month beats 20 in one week.
-
Keep your Yelp profile claimed and accurate, but let reviews happen naturally.
How to Put This Into Action
-
Log into your Google Business Profile and copy your “Ask for reviews” link.
-
Create a simple review request message (SMS/email).
-
Example: “Thanks for choosing us! If you’d leave a quick Google review, it would mean a lot. Here’s the link: [link].”
-
-
Add “leave us a review” cards, QR codes, or follow-up texts into your customer process.
-
Track growth monthly — if reviews stall, adjust your approach.
Conclusion
Yelp had its moment, but in 2025, Google reviews are the must-have for local businesses. They directly influence your SEO, visibility, and customer trust. Yelp is nice-to-have. Google is non-negotiable.
So if you’re looking for the single best place to focus your review energy this year, the answer is simple: double down on Google — and let Yelp be the side dish.
✅ Call to Action
Need more 5-star Google reviews without chasing customers?
At Local AF Marketing, we set up automated review systems that grow your reputation on autopilot. That means more calls, more jobs, and more loyal customers — while you focus on running your business.
👉 Contact us today to see how we can help you win more leads with Google reviews.